Jason Anderson has received thousands of dollars from local parents and coaches for a clinic and traveling teams. The clinic never happened, the teams were never formed, and Anderson has not refunded any money.
Editor’s note: Several of the sources in this article granted interviews to Inside Dakota Sports only on the condition of anonymity to protect the identity of minors.
RAPID CITY, S.D. — Jason Anderson moved to Rapid City this winter with the intentions of forming the “Anderson Baseball Academy.” He promised local youth players, parents and coaches that he would create traveling teams that would expose young baseball players to college and pro scouts. He even guaranteed to put on a clinic with former professional baseball players as instructors, including Hall of Famer, Rickey Henderson. What he delivered was lies and deceit, according to parents and coaches.
Like many local parents who had dealings with Anderson, one Little League mother of a 10-year-old son, who wishes to remain anonymous, was swayed by his promises. She gave Anderson $3,000 as part of the cost of joining his new youth traveling team. Anderson required that the payment be made in cash. Last Saturday, July 3, this mother drove her son to a youth baseball tournament in Mitchell, S.D., which Anderson claimed to have organized. The mother invited family from across the region to come watch her son play. However, there was no tournament in Mitchell, and Anderson never showed up. After waiting at an empty baseball complex for almost an hour, her 10-year-old son turned to her and said, “He (Anderson) didn’t show up because I’m not good enough.”
“I drained my son’s savings account (to pay Anderson),” she told Inside Dakota Sports. “My whole family went to that tournament. There was not a soul there. He humiliated me in front of my family.”
When she confronted Anderson on the phone about the fact that no tournament had existed in Mitchell, he explained that he was three players short of making a team. When the mother complained that she had driven her son all the way to Mitchell and back, she said that Anderson laughed at her.
To date, the family has not been reimbursed any of the $3,000 they paid to Anderson. The Little League mother told Inside Dakota Sports that she is intending to file a lawsuit against Anderson.
“I’m suing him for the amount of money (he owes me). I have everything that he charged me for on paper – $3,000. Now that it’s all come to a head, and he’s having to explain himself, he’s making all these excuses. Now that I’ve figured this out and have had other people come to me, I know I got suckered in.”
This family is not the only one that has paid Anderson thousands of dollars with no reimbursement. Two local American Legion baseball players, Jake Frederickson and Michael Baldwin, quit their teams in May to join Anderson’s new traveling team, “Team South Dakota.” Both players’ families paid $150 per player to have individual tryouts with Anderson. According to two sources, the players were expected to pay $6,000 to join the team. The money would cover coaching fees, uniforms, travel, food and equipment. In return, the players would travel to showcases and tournaments in which Anderson promised to use his connections to provide the players exposure to college and professional scouts.
Baldwin was told that Team South Dakota’s first game was scheduled for June 12, and that they would be joined by players from across the region, including Eastern South Dakota and Wyoming. Meanwhile, the two players continued to practice together, waiting for the team to take form and begin playing games. June 12 came and went, and no other players joined Team South Dakota. The team never played any games and both players are now back on their American Legion teams. None of the fees paid to Anderson have been reimbursed.
Inside Dakota Sports contacted Anderson for comment regarding these allegations. After a brief phone conversation, he declined to comment over the phone, and requested to receive interview questions by e-mail. Because of the gravity of the charges made against him, Inside Dakota Sports e-mailed Anderson a series of questions. He never responded.
After his arrival in Rapid City, Anderson entered into an informal business agreement with Jason Herz, owner of the Black Hills Batter’s Box. The Batter’s Box is an indoor baseball and softball training facility. According to Herz, Anderson was planning on starting his own baseball academy, much like the business Herz owns. The Batter’s Box was already competing with Rapid City Post 22’s Baseball Academy. Herz decided rather than compete against a second baseball academy, he would attempt a partnership with Anderson.
Anderson told people around town that he was a former minor league baseball player, who once played in the California Angels farm system, and that after playing minor league ball, he played in several independent leagues over the course of a few years. It was in independent ball that Anderson claimed to have developed friendships with former Major League stars, including Donte Bichette, Darrell Evans and Rickey Henderson. Anderson promised that he could get these players and others to come to Rapid City and instruct area youth players at a clinic. Soon after, Anderson and Herz announced the “Training with the Pros” baseball camp.
According to the Rapid City Journal’s March 22 article, “Batter’s Box hosting clinic,” the original date for the camp was scheduled for April 10 and 11. However, because of bad weather, the camp was pushed back a week. The next week the weather was fine, but according to Herz, Anderson said that many of the professional instructors could not make it because of timing and flight problems. In the April 21 online edition of the Rapid City Journal, a posting read: “After being extended once before, Saturday is the final registration day for the “Training with the Pros” clinic at the The Batter’s Box. The clinic is April 30-May 2 at Pete Lien Field, and will feature instruction from more than 20 former professional baseball players, including Major League All-Stars and even a Hall of Famer.”
Ultimately, the “Training with the Pros” clinic never happened.
According to Herz, The Batter’s Box received $2,500 from local parents who registered their sons for the camp. The checks were made out to The Batter’s Box, and the money was transferred to Anderson. To date, Herz has either repaid or offered free lessons at The Batter’s Box to children whose parents paid for the camp. Inside Dakota Sports interviewed parents who signed up for the camp, and all of them confirmed that they had either been refunded, or received free lessons from Herz in exchange for the amount they paid. All parents interviewed by Inside Dakota Sports spoke on condition of anonymity and did not want their children to be identified.
In all, parents, coaches and Herz have told Inside Dakota Sports that Anderson was paid $33,000. No one has been paid back. Additional efforts were made to reach Anderson at the Best Western Motel in Rapid City where he has been staying. He did not answer his phone. Sources told Inside Dakota Sports that two separate lawsuits will be filed against Jason Anderson.
*If you have paid Jason Anderson money for your child to participate in one of his enterprises, contact Inside Dakota Sports.
Additional reporting on this story was contributed by Morandi Hurst.







First off the guy lives out of a Best Western Hotel. Secondly anyone wanting to deal in cash is not involved in legit dealings. I learned that in 8th grade. The money part is terrible, and the legion kids are old enough to know that they’ve been had, but to take that kind of money and do that to a ten year old is ludicrous. Not to be mean but I’m pretty sure we called this from the beginning, when you first reported the traveling team made up by some no name back in May. But dreamers are most often failures. All the parents need to get their lawyers on the line and get the ball rolling before Jason Anderson moves to a Super 8 in Creston Iowa and does it to another group of kids next spring. Just another reason to stick with what you know…….community orginized baseball.
Excellent story. Some of us who have worked in athletics for years are fully aware of people like this and TRY to warn parents of what goes on but most fail to listen ….. Hopefully all parents will learn a lesson from this. I also hope everyone will be reimbursed. This was an outstanding investigative story.
Mr Anderson has broke the law.. How come guys like this get away with scams? Because suing him is a waste of time and no one ever goes after them. $30 thousand might be worth the trouble and time.
What a horrible deal. Unfortunately their is no way to rid the world of bad people with no conscience. Con artists have an unbelievable knack of finding vulnerable people to prey on (i.e. new businesses and high school ball players looking for an opportunity).
Is the above comment from the Messer that currently coaches legion baseball in Rapid? That’s a little harsh and irrisponsible if you ask me. Especially since the most successful people I have ever met were also the biggest dreamers. Taking shots at 17 year old kids who just got the rug pulled out from under them is extremely childish. I’d love to hear more of your insight about how to avoid failure.
Maybe our comments should be geared towards the criminal here and not the individuals and businesses that were taken advantage of. Chances are, they have been through enough already.
I am one of the parents who had a child registered in this so called clinic. I think it’s important that people understand that Jason Herz and The Batter’s Box were completely honest with us throughout this ordeal. I have sent my son to The Batter’s Box clinics in the past and they were great experiences which is why we were excited for this one. However, Jason did tell us that he was more of an investor in this clinic and that Anderson was organizing the whole thing because of his “connections”. I think it’s probably safe to say that one of the law suits mentioned was probably filed by The Batter’s Box.
I do not coach baseball. I don’t even live in South Dakota.
I do not coach baseball in Rapid City. I was in no way taking shots at the 17 yr olds. I was simply stating that they are old enough to understand what happened and that Mr. Anderson was a con, where a 10 year old thought it was because he wasn’t good enough. A young kid may not understand what had happened. It’s terrible for everyone involved, including Mr. Herz, that really didn’t have anything to do with Mr. Anderson’s actions. He showed his class by reimbursing everyone that had been effected and in no way should take any blame for it.
The dreamers comment, I agree after reading, sounded like I was taking a shot at the parents and kids, but I was directing that towards Mr. Anderson’s statements from a previous story about the future of Rapid City baseball. If it seemed I was directing it the wrong way, I’ll own that.
I’m not Glen Beck, I was not trying to perceive evil as good and vise versa.
This story is good reporting.. It is good to get the word out about this crook/ con artist. Jason Anderson needs to be behind bars his initials are JA that is also what this guy is (a real Jack A##) I have been taking my son Brady to the Batter’s Box for almost 2 years and have gotten to know Jason Herz very well. He is a great guy who is there to promote baseball in R.C. and help our players get noticed no matter what team they play for. He just wants to share his love and knowledge for baseball with anybody who plays the game. Thank you Jason Herz!!!!!
Great story Jake! And nice job by Morandi! This is a heck of a story. Stuff like this is what sets your website apart from and above the others. Thanks for telling the tale, and reminding us to be cautious.
Mike,you clearly lack skill of articulation. What you are trying to say and what you are saying, are not the same. I find it funny that you hear stories of a charismatic person duping people who do have dreams,yet you find it more so their fault for being duped.I guess you have never been fooled in your life and I somehow doubt you would admit to it if you had in light of your previous comments. To imply a 17 year old baseball player is a worldly sage,versed in the ability to smell a scam shows you to not even be a parent.
I do agree that this needs to be posted everywhere. I think people do not need to take this on the cheek and write it off. It needs to be addressed and handled by every parent who was manipulated.
Coming from a family that bleeds baseball,all 5 of my kids play, I know how easy…HOW EASY, Mike, it is to say a few words and see an 18 year olds eyes glaze over and he be ready to do anything he is asked by a person with the right attitude. I see my eldest child’s coach tell him a few things and it is as if he was handed words down from the all mighty himself….that’s part of being a child and having a dream. It is a shame when someone takes the time to piss on it and make a buck to boot. Thanks for reporting the story, I hope he gets what he deserves. I will ensure this is passed on from page to page and site to site.
Unbelievable…I’m just enraged by what this degenerate has done. My heart goes out to the parents, players and to Mr. Herz. Regardless of whether this Anderson fellow was an obvious phony to some people or not (which my hat goes off to IDS for reporting on this possibility earlier this year) the people that were scammed by him are not to blame. They are victims of a shady master of deceit who abused the dreams and aspirations of young players and the families who want to see them succeed. I commend Mr. Herz for his attempt to give opportunities to these players despite the outcome and it is sad that taking that chance has also left him high and dry.
It is unfortunate that these too-good-to-be-true deals often turn out to be just that. I am glad that the two older players still get a chance to play ball with the Legion teams and it shows that our community baseball teams have the “moral fiber” to welcome back players who chose to leave those teams during the middle of the season. I’m sure it was hard for those coaches to see some of their players leave in pursuit of what they thought was a better chance at being successful and it shows how excellent the leadership is at our Legion teams. American Legion baseball will never scam you. It provides excellent training, exposure and the important emphasis on team play.
I will remain hopeful that this crook is put behind bars and can’t say enough about the excellent investigative reporting done by the IDS staff. I personally cannot think of anyone or any source out there that is more dedicated to excellence in journalism than the staff at IDS, and this article proves that point. To say that this is just a sports site is a completely shortsighted understatement. This is front “page” news that goes beyond the category of sports alone. I am thankful that their are journalists such as yourselves in this community that are actually committed to going above and beyond. I look forward to your further coverage of this issue. Keep up the good work.
Sad story all around. I will stick up for Mr. Messer though Mike is one of the most understanding and outstanding individuals you will ever meet. I personally don’t think he meant anything in anyway to say these Legion players were stupid or dumb. To lash out at Mike is completely wrong he didn’t do anything wrong Mr. Anderson did….. to Mike I say you are a great individual who has the best intentions at heart and I fully back what you said
What a shame! I hope everyone gets the money they gave Anderson back and Mr Anderson pays the penalty.
For Bob Hardy, I think you should read both posts Mike Messer wrote. He never once took any swipes at the 17 year olds. He was implying that 17 year olds have a better understanding of what being duped is. In the story above the 10 year old said to his mother that the team didn’t show up because he wasn’t good enough. He doesn’t understand that he and his family were scammed. The 17 year olds understand that it wasn’t because they weren’t good enough. Both are a shame, but the older kids have a better understanding.
Some of his remarks were smart, but not untrue. But this story is about Jason Anderson and his wrong doings, not some random comments by random guy on IDS.
My hearts go out to these kids! I’m sure they have put so much time and effort into getting where they are today only to be had by a JERK! I’m sure Jason Anderson is keeping up on the responses so here’s one for you Jason…
I know who you are and I know you’re style. Take this message how you will… But to do what you did to these hardworking families and their children is despicable! Karma is a wonderful thing, and you are going to get yours! I just hope all these people you screwed over are there to see it when you get what’s coming to you. Maybe everyone can carpool on a road trip to visit what a sorry excuse for a man you are in prison!
Get a life loser!
To the families out there who have suffered, I hope your suites go through and even if your money isn’t returned maybe from your loss you’ll really win by putting a scam artist behind bars for good!
Jake: do you have a link to the story that Justin Miller refers to with your foreshadowing of this? I can’t find it anywhere. This is all facinating, and REALLY good reporting! Thanks!
Jake,
Heard you on SportsMax this morning. You are doing a great job promoting this great new site! Also great job covering this story about the fraud of the baseball kids. Hopefully the kids will get their money back from this crook. I love this site and keep up the suberb work!
[...] to Harvard, er, the major leagues. Media reports put the money lost at anywhere from $25,000 to $33,000, though I suspect that’s a bit low. A baseball camp organizer said he lost $18,500, and [...]
This really is a horrible story, but I do agree with Mike in some ways. 17 year olds who are good baseball players should know that Legion baseball is the way to go. Is it their fault they got fooled? not at all and I feel for them, but if you’re a good enough player you’ll be found you don’t have to go play for an “elite” traveling team. Traveling teams like that usually turn out to be kind of a crapshoot on whether the competition is really that good anyway. I’d really like to know what happens to this guy.