
Long time Post 22 assistant coach Rich Downs will not seek the head coaching job for Post 22. (Photo Kevin Cox/IDS)
Every leading man has a sidekick.
Never center stage, never in the limelight, forever a partner, but never a bright star, sidekick’s toil in anonymity. The Lone Ranger had his Tonto. Batman had his Robin. Butch had Sundance. One common thread defines their dramatic role. They are forever showing up at the last minute to save their impulsive heroes.
Post 22 baseball assistant coach Rich Downs has played the role of trusted sidekick to Dave Ploof for 29 years, and when Ploof announced his retirement last month, it was natural for local baseball fans to assume that Downs was the heir apparent.
But Baseball Parents, Inc., the governing board of Post 22 baseball, is more than halfway through the two-week process of receiving applications for the head coach position, and with only a few days remaining, Rich Downs has not applied for the job.
Downs recently confirmed to Inside Dakota Sports that he will not seek the job of head coach.
“No. I’m not planning to apply.” Downs said. “I think the program needs a youth movement. New blood. New thinking. I’m getting older, and I think I’m on the edge of not being able to relate to the younger players. I’m more of a college guy. I’m more old school. Baseball has stayed the same. But the way a coach needs to relate with kids these days has changed. If I was going to coach Post 22, I’d have to go to clinics and talk to younger coaches just to learn how to motivate the players.”
Baseball Parents, Inc. board member Jeff Stone has been given the responsibility of accepting the first round of coaching applications. Stone told IDS Tuesday afternoon that “five or six people have applied”.
IDS has confirmed that Post 22 assistant coach Mitch Messer has applied.

Mitch Messer, 32, twice 'American Legion Coach of the Year', in Montana has applied for the head coaching job. He is entering his third year as a coach with Post 22. (Photo Jake Nordbye/IDS)
“Yes. I sent my resume and a list of references.” Messer explained. “No one has contacted me for an interview. I don’t know what happens next.”
Stone also confirmed that Dave Collins, a graduate of the Post 22 program, who went on to play 16 seasons in the Major Leagues as well as being a coach at the Major League level has also applied.
“Yeah, he’s an applicant. “ Stone said. “He’s contacted us about the position. To be honest, I don’t know if it offers enough for him to move back to Rapid City to do it, but he has contacted us.”
Stone told IDS that after the application period closes next week the Board will review the applications, select the six most qualified, and submit those to Dave Ploof, the Director of Baseball Operations for the Post 22 baseball program. Ploof will conduct a background check and review the applications before submitting his recommendations to the board.
“The intent was for him, because he knows a lot of people through his years in baseball, just to contact them and give the board a feel for what he thinks.” Stone explained. “If he doesn’t like one of our own coaches that we like, I don’t think he could say, ‘Well, he’s out.’”
IDS asked Stone if Ploof had veto power.
“No. No. That’s not the intention. I’m not sure exactly how the process will work. We haven’t done this for 47 years. But Coach Ploof will have a limited role in some things, and he has agreed to that.”
“I’ve heard some people criticize the Board because they thought we were doing it internally. Now we’re not.” Stone continued. “They say, ‘You guys don’t know what you’re doing.’ Well, we’re just trying to follow a proper protocol. The proper way to do it is, you open the process up. You take applicants. And you pick the best applicant. Obviously, we think that what we have already (the existing Post 22 coaching staff) is a pretty good deal. But it is still important to do the right process and pick the right person.”
Despite their efforts to use a properly transparent, orderly process to select the next coach, Downs’ decision not to apply leaves the Board with big questions. If Dave Ploof is Director of Baseball Operations, and someone new is hired to be head coach, is there a place for Downs in the future of the program?
Stone’s response was: “There is a proposal from the coaches (of Post 22), and they have a plan in place that does include Rich.”
While the Board of Baseball Parents, Inc. has been moving deliberately toward the Post Ploof era, it is now clear that behind the scenes the coaching staff has been playing a major role.








Messer.
So let me post the question that everyone is thinking.
Dave Collins? Since when does he care about Rapid City baseball?
Answer: Since Dave Ploof called to recruit him
This is manipulation at it’s finest. Be strong BPI, the future of baseball in Rapid City truly depends on your ability to make the right decision here.
Ploof has quickly gone from a man I thought deserved a statue in front of the stadium, to a man that should be permanently banned from the stadium….and that’s too bad.
As with all sidekicks, you never truly know how much reign they are given by the top dog. However, I believe Coach Downs is the man that picked up and rebuilt the psyche of many a Post 22 player in the wake of Coach Ploof’s methodology. He is a man of character who I believe always has the best interests of the players at heart. His self-introspection and assessment in approach the potential role of Head Coach is admirable. While I think he can relate much better to kids then he gives himself credit for, I respect his decision.
Too bad more coaches aren’t like him.
Thanks, Rich for what you’ve done for kids over the years. Keep doing it!
If anyone should have a say in the next coach it should be Rich Downs, not Dave Ploof. I have never heard of a senile old C.E.O. losing his grip, being allowed to choose their replacement, or even have a say.
Mitch Messer is no doubt the best choice. My first impression is that Mitch will be a visable and a great public relations instrument for Post 22. His accomplishments in Montana speak for themself. I also thank coach Downs for his many contributions to the program. Coach Messer would be one I’d want my children to learn from……….
During Mr. Messer’s stay at Bozeman he was two wins and one loss againt Post 22. I think allot of coaches would like to have that stat. I may be a little bias, but I think he is more than capable.
MESSER BY FAR AND AWAY IS THE BEST CANDIDATE OUT THERE. HE WILL BRING MANY YOUNG MEN THE JOY OF PLAYING BASEBALL THE RIGHT WAY……
I just had a thought, could this be all ego driven? Is there a chance that the true fear is not whether Post 22 will be worse off without the prior skipper, but perhaps that the current coaches (all solid individuals and talented coaches) will take the team to higher levels, more regional championships, World Series appearances? That would truly be a dagger in the heart of an exiting egomaniac. Of course that is not the case here… I was just thinking out loud.
Messer is the pick. Every thing else is just wasted time. He knows how to relate to the kids, parents, board,the community, and more importantly, the sponsors. Talent is great, but the next generation coach must be a financial minded CEO that knows baseball. Messer is that.
I have a few questions? When was the last time the Dave Collins has been back to RC? He has a little league field named after him, and what has he done to give back to the youth that play on said field? He is only after what he thinks is a fat check! I would want my son to play for coaches that are willing to make a long term investment into the program and the kids and bring back credibility and respect that quite frankly has been squandered from the program by an eqotistical coach that has not been about the kids or the game for a long time(run-on sentence,ha ha). Messer, Downs, Yamada, and Barbier should be taking this program to baseball prominence where it belongs. And if anyone thinks that Dave Ploof has the patent on that then they are as brainwashed and Dave Ploof himself! Baseball Parents, do the right thing and make the call NOW!!! For the kids and the sake of the program, make the right decision soon….
Just Curious – what does the job of Post 22 head coach pay??
How old was Dave Ploof when he became head coach?